Manliness

Manliness

Harvey Mansfield / Aug 22, 2019

Manliness This book invites no demands a response from its readers It is impossible not to be drawn in to the provocative often contentious discussion that Harvey Mansfield sets before us This is the first com

  • Title: Manliness
  • Author: Harvey Mansfield
  • ISBN: 9780300106640
  • Page: 124
  • Format: Hardcover
  • This book invites no, demands a response from its readers It is impossible not to be drawn in to the provocative often contentious discussion that Harvey Mansfield sets before us This is the first comprehensive study of manliness, a quality both bad and good, mostly male, often intolerant, irrational, and ambitious Our gender neutral society does not like it but canThis book invites no, demands a response from its readers It is impossible not to be drawn in to the provocative often contentious discussion that Harvey Mansfield sets before us This is the first comprehensive study of manliness, a quality both bad and good, mostly male, often intolerant, irrational, and ambitious Our gender neutral society does not like it but cannot get rid of it.Drawing from science, literature, and philosophy, Mansfield examines the layers of manliness, from vulgar aggression, to assertive manliness, to manliness as virtue, and to philosophical manliness He shows that manliness seeks and welcomes drama, prefers times of war, conflict, and risk, and brings change or restores order at crucial moments Manly men in their assertiveness raise issues, bring them to the fore, and make them public and political as for example, the manliness of the women s movement.After a wide ranging tour from stereotypes to Hemingway and Achilles, to Nietzsche, to feminism, and to Plato, the author returns to today s problem of unemployed manliness Formulating a reasoned defense of a quality hardly obedient to reason, he urges men, and especially women, to understand and accept manliness, and to give it honest and honorable employment.

    The Art of Manliness Official Site Will You Answer the Call of the New Strenuous Age If you ve wanted to take action in your life if you ve wanted to strengthen yourself in body, mind, and spirit, but haven t known where to start, then The Strenuous Life is for you. Manliness Define Manliness at Dictionary Manly, manful, mannish mean having the traits or qualities that a culture regards as especially characteristic of or ideally appropriate to adult men Manly is usually a term of approval, suggesting traits admired by society, such as determination, decisiveness, and steadiness a manly acceptance of the facts manly firmness of character Manful, also a term of approval, stresses qualities Manly Skills Archives The Art of Manliness Get Skilled The Art of Manliness seeks to help men overcome their fears of style by offering an alternative to those who believe there s to being a stylish Manliness Harvey C Mansfield Manliness is an essay in definition, defense, and due criticism of the spirited assertiveness that men have in their nature and that a few men and a very few women think Margaret Thatcher have in spades Art of Manliness YouTube Manliness definition of manliness by The Free Dictionary Of, relating to, or characteristic of men, especially when considered traditionally masculine, as in being courageous or direct Few men who are just about to go off on an adventure can resist a manly swig from a convenient bottle of whisky Jane Stevenson. Art of Manliness artofmanliness Twitter Manliness book Manliness is a book by Harvey C Mansfield first published by Yale University Press in Mansfield is a professor of government at Harvard University.In this book, he defines manliness as confidence in a situation of risk and suggests this quality is currently undervalued in Western society. The Art of Manliness Store Manly Apparel, Accessories Gear Apparel for the Art of Manliness Man to live an excellent, flourishing life. Art Of Manliness Is Poisoning The Concept Of Masculinity I ve perused the website Art of Manliness a few times in the past year Something always vaguely turned me off about it, with its smug, woman friendly, safe, feel good presentation, and those feelings have recently hardened into outright hostility.

    • [PDF] Download ✓ Manliness | by ✓ Harvey Mansfield
      124 Harvey Mansfield
    • thumbnail Title: [PDF] Download ✓ Manliness | by ✓ Harvey Mansfield
      Posted by:Harvey Mansfield
      Published :2018-010-09T09:09:16+00:00

    About "Harvey Mansfield"

      • Harvey Mansfield

        Harvey Claflin Mansfield, Jr is a Professor of Government at Harvard University.He has held Guggenheim and NEH Fellowships and has been a Fellow at the National Humanities Center he also received the National Humanities Medal in 2004 and delivered the Jefferson Lecture in 2007 He is a Carol G Simon Senior Fellow at Stanford University s Hoover Institution He is notable for his generally conservative stance on political issues in his writings.Mansfield is the author and co translator of studies of and or by major political philosophers such as Aristotle, Edmund Burke, Niccol Machiavelli, Alexis de Tocqueville, and Thomas Hobbes, of Constitutional government, and of Manliness 2006 Among his most notable former students are Andrew Sullivan, Alan Keyes, Robert Kraynak, John Gibbons, William Kristol, Nathan Tarcov, Clifford Orwin, Mark Blitz, Paul Cantor, Delba Winthrop, Mark Lilla, Arthur Melzer, Jerry Weinberger, Francis Fukuyama, Shen Tong, and James Ceaser.


    305 Comments

    1. This book is incredibly forthright in its gender bias. Mansfield has obviously been endowed by Harvard University to spew their usually conservative and elitist trash. He claims to be aware of gender studies and responding to that body of knowledge but he never truly engages any of the current theory or even ethnographic research. He ignores sexuality completely; he essentializes gender into two very specific and dichotomous categories; and he appears to celebrate/long for the "manly man" exista [...]


    2. Manliness, by the amusingly-named Harvey Mansfield, is not a self-discovery book, although it's shelved with them. Mansfield's thesis is that not much effort has been put into defining and characterizing manliness - both the positive and negative aspects of it. His approach passes the sniff test with regard to the inherent contradictions in the gender-neutral society, and several chapters are spent in a philosophical review of the philosophical underpinnings of feminism and its development. In t [...]


    3. Most will dismiss it without a careful reading. Mansfield is a precise and nuanced thinker. This is a great piece of challenging philosophy that true critical thinkers will appreciate.


    4. So what a guilt-inducing book. My teenage daughter saw the title, read the back cover and said, “Wait, isn’t this a humor book? I don’t get it. Is this guy serious?” Her response, of course, would be viewed as vindication by the author for how far things have gone. So too would have been my laughably unmanly decision to take off its cover when I read it at a local coffee shop so as to not draw attention to its risible title (risible in today’s world). I feel half-heartedly guilty for l [...]


    5. There are many ways to describe my problems with Mansfield's book, but the the most illustrative is to say that Mansfield's treatment of sex differences and by extension his treatment of nature is Hobbesian rather than Platonic. Mansfield constantly says things such as, "[women] are not as manly or as often manly as men" and then uses such observations as the basis for natural sex differences. This mode of argumentation was pioneered by Hobbes, who said that by nature fear of violent death is th [...]


    6. Reading a book called Manliness in public is a little awkward. At first glance it may look like a self-help book to help the unmanly become manly. Although Harvey C. Mansfield has a few things to say about that, Manliness is far more philosophical and academically esoteric than some would expect. In fact, who thinks about "manliness" from an intellectual perspective at all? Mansfield's book is fascinating and important but also a bit laborious.Manliness attempts to define and re-enshrine manline [...]



    7. I did not actually finish reading this book. It is superficial, redundant, and has nothing useful to say.Methinks the man analyzes too much!


    8. This is one of the most boring books I've read. I wish I had quit after the first 50 pages. The author was needlessly long winded, wordy, and obtuse. It drones on and on, uselessly banal, like a student tasked with writing a term paper that requires a minimal number of pages but only has enough material to fill a miniscule amount.The front inside book cover challenges: "This book invites—no, demands—a response from its readers." What manly man would not respond? The book is not at all a "wid [...]


    9. I think the most interesting sentence was the last, "A free society cannot survive if we are so free that nothing is expected of us." I was hoping for a more clear definition of manliness. I left feeling that the author boils it down to assertiveness. Certainly that is an important part of manliness. I find myself following up on feminism. Is the radical feminism merely having women act like men? I'm not so sure. Certainly women sought to act more like men to move away from a passivity which see [...]


    10. Mansfield presents a number of historical examples that reveal the social and psychological costs of second wave feminism, like how the rights and privileges of men have become divorced from the responsibilities of men, and how that has hurt men, women, and children. It's a dense read and really too academic to be completely useful to the lay-reader. I'm looking out for a book that can apply these ideas to more contemporary examples. I think that would be more compelling, and more helpful to men [...]


    11. Not as good as I hoped. Though I consider myself a Straussian (though I don't know what that means), and though I agree with much of what he says (though I don't know much about feminism)--I'd as soon read Allan Bloom. Mansfield's writing did not grip me (I am working on his translation of Tocqueville--that is heavy going too). Of course, I do have a series of trading cards called "Michael's Unmanly Traits Trading Cards" so what do I know.


    12. Some interesting things. Some incomplete things. Some things a tad bit boring. The book has to be applauded for affirming the reality of gender distinctions and identifying "manliness" as a real thing that must be accounted for. At the same time, I'm not sure the author quite gets at true manliness, instead only highlighting partial manliness or reactive manliness.


    13. I kept having to check the publishing date, so much of it seemed a few decades out of time. Yet it was published in 2006. His references, his commentary all speak of an earlier time. I stopped reading after the third chapter. Not worth my time to read this pointless, outdated book. Published in 2006!


    14. Mansfield brings up a lot of good points and offers a reading of numerous classics I had not really considered, at least not consciously. Ultimately, I think he recognized the problem but comes up short of teh solution, yielding to modern society rather than accepting the ends to which his arguments led.


    15. You could really just read the first and the last chapter. An interesting brief run-through of Western philosophy and feminist theory concerning gender. Doesn't really give a solution on how to restore 'manliness' other than what the Greeks say: "Always in moderation".


    16. Polemic monologue. An academic/philosopher's take on the then "current" gender definitions/roles. Somewhat acerbic and occasionally brilliant observations on being manly. I read this book years ago, some of it's "flavour" has stayed with me. Not for everyone.


    17. Somewhat difficult to parse through; Mansfield is a brilliant thinker if at times inconsistent. His insistence on the idea of 'manliness' will irk many, but his gendered readings and projections of literary and philosophical figures and ideas aim to inspire.


    18. Jamie won't let me read this book. But it's fine; this book is so great that it surpasses mere words and actual "reading." Yeah, I know, it's that good. If I could give this book six stars, I would.



    19. Couldn't be bothered to finish the book. Mansfield approaches an interesting topic but fails to provide a complete theory; instead his insights remain parochial.


    20. Okay, I get it, and I agree with much of it, but this is one heck of a hard book to read. Make sure you've had Philosophy 101 and 201 before jumping into to this one.







    21. A great work of political philosophy, and something of a polemic against modern feminism. Mansfield's intellectual history of feminism suffices as a critique of feminism, res ipsa loquitur.



    22. Interesting, but even for me, a bit wordy. Basic thesis was good (in my opinion), but some of the passages were needlessly obtuse. Coming from me, that's saying something.


    Leave a Reply